|
|
.
|
Newsletter - April 30, 2003
Starwood Hotels posts quarterly loss
Chain warns future profits will fall
short
The company, which like the rest of the travel industry is
also being hurt by the outbreak of the SARS virus, warned its future profit
would fall below Wall Street forecasts. White Plains, New York,-based Starwood
reported a loss of $117 million, or 58 cents per share, in the first quarter,
compared with a profit of $32 million, or 16 cents per share, a year earlier.
Excluding impairment charges from the expected sale of some hotels, the
company said its quarterly loss was 8 cents a share.
Hit by a travel downturn which also led rivals to slash outlooks, Starwood on
March 24 withdrew its forecast of about a 4-cent per share profit. Analysts
polled by Thomson First Call had seen anywhere from a 10-cent loss to a profit
of 2 cents per share, with an average estimate of a loss of 2 cents.
Revenue fell to $1.07 billion from $1.09 billion a year earlier.
The company said the effect of the SARS outbreak and geopolitical instability
on the travel industry have made it difficult to forecast financial results.
But Starwood said it expects second-quarter profit excluding
special items to reach between 20 cents per share and 25 cents per share
and earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization between
$230 million and $240 million.
For 2003, the company said in a statement it expects profit excluding
special items between 70 cents per share and 80 cents per share and
earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization between
$930 million and $950 million.
The average First Call estimate was a second-quarter profit of 35 cents a
share and a full year profit of 83 cents a share.
Shares of Starwood are up about 12 percent for the year, compared with an
8 percent rise by the Standard & Poor’s hotel index (.GSPHOTL)
Investors have been waiting for Iraqi situation to stabilize, which they
hope will improve the outlook for travel. But industry executives have
steadily reduced earnings outlooks for months, pointing to continued
economic weakness.
Hilton Hotels Corp. and Marriott International
Inc., the other two top-three U.S. hotel companies, in their quarterly
reports said businesses were still waiting for their own profits to pick
up before resuming travel and forecast revenue per available room, a key
barometer of health in the lodging industry, would drop 1 percent to 2
percent this year
For detailed Financial Highlights, Click
Here
March
2003: The crisis continues!
The difficult international context and
the breakdown in the worldwide economy - the crisis evident in the
Parisian upscale industry is now spreading throughout France.
In Paris, occupancy was not the only
indicator to suffer last month (-19%), since even ARR was down by -5%.
This is particularly worrying and could indicate the risk of a
price war - not seen since the last Iraqi conflict.
In March, only Large Capacity hotels managed to increase ARR,
with a modest rise of 2%. Other
categories experienced stagnating (deluxe hotels) or declining ARR (-7%
for boutique hotels).
This drop in ARR would not be so
dramatic if it wasn't for the simultaneous decline in occupancy.
Occupancy dropped by -9% for First Class hotels and a massive
-33% for the Palaces! The
latter, who since 11th September 2001, had been maintaining their
performances, are now posting the biggest declines seen in years. Even September and October 2001 saw better performances.
The strong dependence of Palaces on the American and Middle East
markets explains this. Lastly, RevPAR dropped by -23%, on average:
First Class hotels lost 'only' -14% and Palaces -34%.
Parisian midscale hotels did not fare
much better. Contrary to
the months of January and February, occupancy dropped fairly
significantly (-9% for 2 stars and -14% for the two 3 star categories).
The +1% increase in ARR was not sufficient to offset the decline
in occupancy. Consequently,
RevPAR dropped by -7% for 2 star hotels and -15% for standard 3 stars.
Regional hotels recorded occupancy
decreases, albeit in proportion to the category of hotel.
Upscale units were more significantly impacted (-9%), whilst 2
stars only posted a -3% drop. Nevertheless,
regional hotels appeared to be resisting the crisis, somewhat, thanks to
increases in average rates. ARR
rose by +5% for 4 star hotels and +8% for 2 stars.
Upscale establishments, only, recorded drops in RevPAR.
Three star hotels' RevPAR stagnated (+1%) and 2 stars' rose by
+5%, thanks to higher ARR.
Note:
Grand Luxe = Deluxe Hotels; Hôtels de Charme = Boutique Hotels;
Gros Porteurs = Large Capacity Hotels
Upscale Parisian
Hotels
Midscale
Parisian Hotels
Regional
Hotels
News@PATA
DE JONG AND TRAVEL INDUSTRY TO MEET WHO DIRECTOR
PATA President and CEO, Mr. Peter de Jong, and other travel
industry leaders, will meet with the WHO Executive Director Mr. David L.
Heymann at a press briefing tonight at the Foreign Correspondents’ Club of
Thailand in Bangkok. Mr. Heymann will meet with ASEAN leaders at the emergency
summit on SARS in Bangkok tomorrow (29th). Mr. de Jong said: "It will be
a good chance for PATA and the travel industry to request that countries which
have made progress containing SARS should be removed from the WHO’s advisory
list. It is important we make the WHO understand the severe economic hardship
which our members are experiencing as a result of its advisories."
WHO INVITES FAQs ON SARS
The World Health Organization (WHO) will expand
its frequently-asked questions about SARS on its Web site (http://www.who.int/csr/sars/sarsfaq/en/)
to include more travel-related information. PATA and the International Air
Transport Association (IATA) are compiling proposed FAQs to send to the WHO.
PATA ATTENDS IATA SARS MEETING
On April 23 senior PATA executives attended an IATA seminar
in Bangkok on SARS. Senior airline executives from around the world heard
testimony from airline leaders, executives from the World Health Organization
and the U.S.-based Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. After attending
the event, PATA President and CEO, Mr. Peter de Jong, said he was deeply
concerned. "Our carriers, airport, hotel and tour operators are hurting
very badly. The public debate needs perspective. For example, out of about 200
million airline passenger trips since SARS began there have only been five
confirmed cases of in-flight transmission and these occurred before
screening procedures were put in place at check-in."
BUSINESS AS USUAL FOR PATA
Despite the outbreak of SARS, PATA executives are
continuing travelling as usual. PATA President and CEO will this week deliver
the keynote address at a major industry function in Dubai organised by
Emirates. On return he will fly to Dhaka, Bangladesh, May 5-8, for talks with
the country’s President, Prime Minister and Tourism Minister. PATA Vice
President Mr. Peter Semone will visit Macau SAR and Hong Kong SAR this week to
talk to tourism leaders on what PATA can do to help destinations badly
affected by SARS cancellations.
TIMOR LESTE BECOMES PATA GOVERNMENT MEMBER
The youngest country in the world, Timor Leste (formerly
known as East Timor), has joined PATA following PATA Vice President, Mr. Peter
Semone’s trip to Dili last week. Mr. Semone met with Prime Minister, Mr.
Mari Alkatiri and Secretary of State of Tourism, Environment and Investment,
Mr. Jose Teixeira. Mr. Semone said: "Timor Leste has world-class beaches
and scuba diving plus numerous land-based attractions. The destination needs
investment, but it has a very bright tourism future ahead of it."
TRAVELRADIO HOSTS CONFERENCE HIGHLIGHTS
Mr. Russ Johnson of Travelmedia has uploaded three audio
interviews and a visual clip of a cultural performance at PATA Annual
Conference in Bali, Indonesia, to the PATAradio Web site at http://www.travelmedia.com/PATAradio/.
By simply clicking on the links you can hear PATA Strategic Intelligence
Centre Managing Director, Mr. John Koldowski, analysing the impact of SARS,
Tourism Tropical North Queensland Chief Executive Officer, Mr. Bill Calderwood,
on communicating with governments, and Accor Senior Vice President Asia
Pacific, Mr. Brian Deeson, on how small companies can win the PR battle
without breaking the bank. The link to PATAradio is also available from www.pata.org.
KOREA (ROK) IMPRESSED BY BALI CONFERENCE
PATA HQ-based Consultant, Mr. Kim Kwang-Nam, said delegates
from Korea (ROK) were impressed by the 52nd PATA Annual Conference in Bali,
Indonesia. The 53rd PATA Annual Conference, Jeju Island, in April 2004 will be
jointly organised by the Jeju provincial government and the Korea National
Tourism Organization (KNTO).
FIRST REAL-TIME CONFERENCE MEDIA CENTRE
During the 52nd PATA Annual Conference in Bali, Indonesia,
the PATA media centre utilised network technology to provide real-time
information flows to journalists. When a speaker’s presentation or speech
arrived at the media centre it was held on the master workstation for cosmetic
touch-ups. The moment the speaker’s session ended, the speech was uploaded
electronically on to eight media workstations. Images taken by the Conference
photographer were also uploaded onto the media workstations after professional
scanning and captioning. Conference speeches are currently available online to
all PATA members at www.pata.org.
JERRY PICOLLA WINS FIRST PRESIDENT’S STAFF AWARD
Mr. Jerry Picolla received a standing ovation during the
PATA Annual Conference closing session when he was announced as the first
winner of the PATA President’s Staff Award. Former PATA Executive Vice
President, the late Mr. Marvin F. Plake, hired Mr. Picolla as a consultant 30
years ago. Mr. Picolla later took charge of marketing and chapter development
and created the PATA Travel Mart concept. "Jerry can truly be identified
as the father of chapter development on a world-wide basis," Mr. de Jong
said. "He is one of the most respected PATA staff members in the history
of our Association."
PATA EDIT SCHOLARSHIP WINNERS ANNOUNCED
PATA is pleased to award four scholarships to the Executive
Development Institute for Tourism (EDIT) Programme, operated by the School of
Travel Industry Management, University of Hawaii at Manoa. The Jerome A.
Keller Memorial Scholarship went to Western Australian Tourism Commission
Director of Industry Development, Mr. David Etherton. Fiji Visitors Bureau
Senior Marketing Officer, Ms. Sala Toganivalu Lesuma, received the PATA
Foundation Scholarship. The two remaining scholarships went to Journey Plus's
Mr. Taufiq Rahman from Bangladesh and SriLankan Airlines Industry Affairs
Executive (MICE), Mr. Chinthaka Weerasinghe. For further information contact
aye@pata.th.com.
CONFERENCE SPEECHES AVAILABLE TO PATA MEMBERS
Twenty-six PATA Annual Conference speeches and
presentations are now available in the members-only area of www.pata.org.
They are in MS Word or MS PowerPoint format.
MEETINGS INDUSTRY MARKETING AND RESEARCH MEETING
The International Congress and Convention Association’s (ICCA’s)
fourth Regional International Congress and Convention Researchers Meeting (ICCRM)
will be held in Auckland, New Zealand, August 7-9, 2003. The ICCRM focuses on
research and marketing in the meetings industry. For more information, please
visit www.iccaworld.com/iccrm2003/auckland.
PATA STRATEGIC INTELLIGENCE CENTRE WORLDWATCH
** The Association of Asia Pacific Airlines (AAPA) and the
International Air Transport Association (IATA) are pressuring airport
authorities in Hong Kong SAR and Japan to reduce landing and other fees to
help airlines weather the SARS outbreak. Singapore, Chinese Taipei, Dubai,
Cyprus, Athens, Melbourne and Brisbane airports have already cut user charges.
** Singapore hotel employees now have to pass a temperature
test before starting their shift as part of the local industry’s SARS
prevention strategy. Employees who pass must then wear stickers that declare
them fit to work. The Singapore Tourism Board is expected to announce a
complete hotel certification scheme this week.
** Thai Airways
International has prepared a "total solution" to the problems it
faces in the current industry crisis. THAI’s plan involves cutting costs for
almost everything except publicity about its SARS prevention measures
Sharp rise in SA hotel investment
Business Day - As part of the growing interest in South
Africa's tourism and leisure industry, particularly on the part of offshore
investors, Golding Hotel Investment Consultants (GHIC), part of Pam Golding
Properties, South Africa's largest unlisted residential property group, has
concluded deals in excess of R220 million for the financial year ended
February 2003, the group said on Tuesday.
This represents an increase of 76% over the previous year.
At the same time, according to GHIC managing director Joop Demes, a survey
of 25 of the major hotel operators in the industry in the centres of Cape Town
and Johannesburg reflected an average increase in revenue per available room
of 25% to 35% for the 12-month period ended December 2002, compared with the
previous year.
This greatly increased traffic in the main centres is having a positive
spillover effect into other areas such as the Cape Winelands, and the
eco-tourism or game farming areas of Mpumalanga, as well as the Garden Route
area.
"While global instability is placing global hotel operators under
tremendous pressure, the industry in South Africa is bucking this trend
aggressively, further boosted by increased tourism and high-profile events
such as the World Summit and Cricket World Cup," Demes said.
"Delegates and visitors to two recent major international trade shows -
the International Trade Show in Berlin and the World Trade Market in London -
reconfirmed the huge interest in and popularity of South Africa as a tourist
destination."
Demes added that while it was still more cost-effective for foreign
investors to buy an existing operation than to build, it was exciting to see a
growing trend towards new buildings being constructed, which include two
5-star country boutique hotels in the Cape Winelands, a 5-star resort hotel
soon to commence on the Garden Route, and a boutique niche hotel operation - a
new concept popular in the US and Europe that was soon to be introduced in
Cape Town by a UK investor.
"An added attraction is the government's incentive for the hospitality
industry of up to 30% rebate on capital expenditure for the construction of
new buildings or the expansion of existing operations. This of course has
further advantages in terms of creating employment and boosting the
economy."
He said that due to supply and demand Cape Town is attracting a large share
of the greenfields projects, while Gauteng, being more a corporate market, is
also enjoying significantly increased investment in the hospitality and
leisure industry.
As a result, and identifying a gap in the market, GHIC recently launched an
office in Gauteng under Hennie Nasveld, who is also covering the Mpumalanga
area.
Recent transactions concluded by GHIC include:
- A boutique hotel operation in Cape Town CBD sold to an investor from the
UK;
- A country hotel near the Kruger Park sold to a US investor;
- Country hotel on the Garden Route sold to a German investor;
- Sale and lease back of a large five star hotel in the Cape to an
international listed hotel company;
- A new boutique hotel development on the Garden Route being launched by
an investor from the US;
- Two new exclusive hotel operations to be launched on prestigious wine
estates in the Cape Winelands; and
- A country hotel on the outskirts of Johannesburg sold to an investor
from Cyprus.
GHIC is also currently negotiating two further transactions regarding
greenfields projects in Cape Town, while Demes says that in addition, two
offers made in Johannesburg on behalf of foreign investors have been accepted
by the vendor and are currently under due diligence.
He added that foreign investors in the South African hospitality and
leisure market incorporate mainly two different buyer profiles.
First there was the emergence of owner/manager investors from the main
countries which feed South Africa from a tourism point of view, typically the
UK and Germany, who find their home markets overcrowded and are seeking a
guest house or country hotel at an investment of between 4 and 5 million rand
up to 20 million rand.
Then there were corporate investors from America, the UK and further afield
who are prepared to invest from 20 million rand upwards, he said.
Deadly
bug crushing Queensland’s
tourism
The
Mercury -
Queensland’s (Australia) bookings attributed to the outbreak of
severe acute respiratory syndrome.
International airline passenger arrivals from Asia are
plummeting, with some inbound markets down by more than 60 per cent and
falling.
Tourism Queensland
yesterday described short-term expectations of visitors from three key Asian
markets – Singapore, China and Hong Kong – as "disastrous" and
"non-existent". It also warned of downturns in other markets
including Japan.
A spokesman for
Cairns-based reef operator Sunlover Cruises said business had been affected
dramatically by the SARS outbreak, with 700 cancellations last week.
"Our two ships would
normally take out 600-plus passengers a day between them. This week, we've
been taking out 100-a-day total on one ship," managing director Terry
Russell said
Sunlover had put staff on
a four-day-week.
On the Gold Coast, Asian
visitor bookings for the major theme parks were understood to be down by as
much as 40 per cent.
"Singapore, China and
Hong Kong have come to a standstill, and what is holding them back is the
hysteria this disease is creating," Tourism Queensland's marketing
executive director Alex de Waal said.
Industry figures showed
international arrivals at Brisbane Airport for the week to April 20 down 22 per
cent for China, 28 per cent for Japan, which is Queensland's biggest market
with 430,000 visitors a year, 61 per cent for Malaysia, 64 per cent for
Taiwan and 46 per cent for Singapore.
But arrivals increased
from New Zealand (up 13 per cent), the UK (30 per cent) and Germany (29 per
cent).
While the tourism industry
attempts to hold tight, Australian scientists have joined an international
race to develop a diagnostic test for SARS.
The virus has been
imported to Australia, with scientists planning to infect live chickens, pigs
and cats with the virus in a bid to identify a relationship between animal
diseases and SARS in humans.
Overseas, in the
worst-affected nation of China, cinemas, theatres, karaoke bars and internet
cafes have been shut down.
State-run media reported
yesterday all "entertainment businesses involving mass public
gatherings" would be closed in Beijing.
More than 4000 people have
been quarantined in the city with schools, universities and libraries closed.
In Singapore, authorities
plan to issue about 500,000 primary school students with thermometers and
force them to take their temperatures twice a day.
And from today, all food
handlers – from street hawkers to coffee shop workers – will have their
temperatures checked twice daily.
Deaths at the weekend of a
Canadian man, 44, and a Hong Kong resident, 28, proved healthy, younger people
were also at risk from SARS.
In Canada, a World Health
Organisation statement warning people not to travel to Toronto may be lifted
after Canadian authorities claimed it was both unwarranted and damaging to the
economy.
Canadian officials have
complained long and loudly that WHO officials acted without due consideration
for WHO spokesman Dick Thompson said the warning would be reconsidered.
He said Canada had
provided his Geneva-based agency with more information about the outbreak in
Toronto where 20 SARS deaths have occurred.
Jebel Ali International Hotels surges
forward with nationalisation program
AME Info - At the UAE Careers Fair 2003, Jebel Ali
International Hotels has reiterated that it is constantly working to recruit
more UAE nationals into its management training program, thus increasing its
already high number of UAE national employees
Jebel Ali International Hotels currently employs the highest number of UAE
nationals in the UAE hospitality industry, both on a management and trainee
level.
During the Careers Fair, which took place this week, Jebel Ali International
Hotels exhibited its training and employment opportunities within the Group in
order re-confirm its desire to maximise local talent and provide training for
future managers and directors of the hospitality industry.
His Highness Sheikh Nahyan bin Mubarak Al Nahyan – UAE Minister of Higher
Education & Scientific Research and Chancellor of the Higher Colleges of
Technology, visited the Jebel Ali International Hotels stand at the Careers
Fair and congratulated Gerhard Hardick, General Manager of Jebel Ali
International Hotels on leading the local hospitality market in promoting,
training and employing UAE nationals.
Ghanim Al Marri, Assistant Manager Human Resources, Jebel Ali International
Hotels said, “We have been recruiting UAE nationals into our management
trainee program since 1998 and since this time have put our recruits through
six months of initial management training before placing them into the area
they are best suited to. We currently have these employees working in a
variety of departments, including front office, accounts and sales.
“The purpose of our road shows is to offer students, both male and female,
an insight into the hospitality industry, offering exciting, challenging and
rewarding careers. With their knowledge of the local market, combined with the
international standards of training provided by Jebel Ali International
Hotels, we are convinced that many of our UAE nationals will go on to take
senior management positions in the future.”
The Jebel Ali International Hotels Group works closely with higher colleges,
universities and schools in the UAE, presenting its careers opportunities to
students and introducing them to the hospitality industry. Educational
institutions such as Dubai Women's College, Zayed University and Sharjah
Women's College are all involved with the Group's recruitment road shows.
Hotel
searches a tricky Web process
Consumer group calls travel Internet sites 'confusing'
Independent Study Reveals Pros and Cons of Wide Variety
of Travel Sites and Reveals Potential for More Complexity and Bias
Consumer WebWatch, a project of Consumers Union, the
non-profit publisher of Consumer Reports magazine, today unveiled a study that
shows the number of unregulated, integrated travel sites on the Internet has
grown, and the complexity of booking rooms and subjectivity of information has
similarly increased. The study on hotel-booking Web sites compares and
contrasts rates and services available through a variety of popular travel
sites.
As part of its mission to improve the credibility of service-oriented Web
sites, Consumer WebWatch undertook its first independent examination of online
hotel-booking services in late February of 2003. The February 2003 project
aimed to determine which sites offer consumers the best services as well as to
provide consumers with guidelines for getting the most out of the popular
sites.
As part of the evaluation process, several of the leading integrated travel
sites were analyzed in controlled, real-time, head-to-head testing, in order
to determine which sites offered the most thorough displays and lowest rates
for hotel rooms. The sites tested included Expedia, Hotels.com, Lodging.com,
Orbitz and Travelocity, as well as several branded sites maintained by
national hotel chains.
Methodology:
The testing was benchmarked with Sabre, the leading global distribution system
(GDS) used by travel agencies in the U.S. of hotel booking sites. All testing
was performed by trained individuals and statistical analysis provided by
Consumers Union led to the creation of five separate tests, each consisting of
30 entries, across all seven sites. The testing simulated a variety of trips
in 30 cities throughout the U.S. and the Caribbean. Consumer WebWatch's
research detailed the best and worst sites for searching for hotel rooms by
price, location star ratings, and specific brands and properties. The findings
of the testing were grouped into four major categories: lowest raters, closest
rates, lowest rates by test and lowest average rates.
"For better or worse, the Web has most definitely revolutionized the
travel distribution system," said William McGee, a travel journalist and
consultant to Consumer WebWatch and the Editor of Consumer Reports Travel
Letter from 2000 to 2002. "As more and more consumers turn to the web to
book hotels, it is important that they understand the limitations of
hotel-booking sites."
The research project was completely funded by Consumer WebWatch. Outside
consulting and GDS benchmarking were provided by New York-based Harrell
Associates, Inc., an independent consulting firm.
Among the most significant findings presented by this testing of hotel sites:
-- Overall, Travelocity provided the highest number of lowest rates: 29% in
150 tests, outpacing its nearest competitors, Orbitz (21%) and Expedia (17%).
-- The advent of "Web rates" was a potent factor. In 85% of the
tests, one or more of the six Web sites provided lower rates than Sabre, the
largest GDS used by travel agencies. Sabre and all other GDSs are regulated by
the U.S. Department of Transportation to ensure fair and unbiased listings.
Although Consumer WebWatch included Sabre as a benchmark for these tests, the
lowest rates provided by the GDS were consistently beaten by one or more of
the Web sites, sometimes by hundreds of dollars. The poor performance posted
by Sabre, however, does not mean that travel agencies have lost a competitive
edge. Some travel agents employ a variety of tools to find the best fares and
rates, both online and offline.
-- The lowest average rate was provided by Travelocity. Hotels.com, which did
not perform very well overall, provided the second-lowest average.
-- Overall, the "branded" sites maintained by hotel chains and
specific hotel properties performed rather poorly. But there was one
significant exception: the branded sites outperformed all competitors except
Travelocity and provided the lowest rates in one out of three cases.
-- Orbitz was especially capable of coming quite close to providing the lowest
rates. In 14 separate queries, Orbitz provided rates that were no higher than
$5 per night compared to the lowest rates provided.
-- Expedia, in particular, proved to be quite adept at beating competitive
rates by a very small margin. In several cases, Expedia edged the nearest
competitor by less than $1 per night.
Regarding increasing complexity, one problem common to all five integrated
travel Web sites is that, overall, their search tools are not very intuitive
in the manner of traditional branded search engines, such as Google or Lycos.
These travel sites are quite intolerant when the user incorrectly inputs
information; the slightest mistake in spelling or punctuation can render the
search useless. In addition, when these intolerances are coupled with slight
variances in the listings of specific hotel properties from site to site
(e.g., "Four Points by Sheraton St. Louis Downtown" vs. "Four
Points by Sheraton Downtown St. Louis"), searching can be even more
difficult. It's worth stressing that consumers need to engage in extensive
trouble-shooting when searching for hotel rates on these sites. Multiple
queries are sometimes necessary to obtain the proper rates.
Bias and usability concerns were also unearthed by the study. For example,
even though the integrated travel Web sites tout the power of sophisticated
tools to assist in searching for rates and availability, it's quite clear that
the sites are not offering consumers simple, easy-to-use functionality that
would allow them to search for hotel rates in lowest-to-highest rankings.
In fact, none of these five integrated travel Web sites--Expedia, Hotels.com,
Lodging.com, Orbitz, and Travelocity--offered easy functionality to obtain
lowest rates during the first search. Obtaining lowest-to-highest listings by
price required more advanced searches, when available. Further, these
lowest-to-highest search tools were not always clearly labeled for consumers
to find.
This was one of the most disturbing findings to evolve during this testing.
The supposed value of an integrated site lies in the inherent choices it
offers a consumer, rather than the limited choices offered by branded or
"dealership-model" sites. Although there is little doubt that these
integrated sites have the technological capability to deliver easy-to-use
listings of lowest-to-highest hotel rates, they are not readily doing so.
Consumers may well feel that they are not controlling the interface, and that
in fact these integrated travel Web sites are pushing preferred suppliers at
them.
"The depth and intensity of the testing and investigation of these sites
is unprecedented, and the takeaway for consumers is clear: The convenience and
exclusive Web fares offered by these sites come with a responsibility to dig
deep, and make sure you are really getting as good a deal as you think, at the
property, location and time you want," said Beau Brendler, Director of
Consumer WebWatch.
These questions will likely remain unanswered. In an effort to help consumers
seeking deals on the Internet, Consumer WebWatch has developed practical tips
for consumers shopping for a hotel room on the Web.
Consumer WebWatch Tips for Booking Hotels Online
-- Keep shopping around. Yes, Consumers Union has issued this warning
before--more than once. But it remains the single most important piece of
advice to help you find the best travel bargains online. For context: After
extensive testing and analysis, Travelocity emerged as the winner in this
session of hotel testing. And yet Travelocity's strong performance needs to be
put into context. Simply put, Travelocity failed to return the lowest hotel
rate more than 70% of the time. All the other sites performed even worse. If
it's important to you to find the best rates and fares, you need to consult
more than one site.
-- Always ensure that the rate you've found is available for immediate
booking. The better sites will provide explanations of their booking policies.
-- Before booking a hotel room online, make sure you've determined the final
rate. There may be additional charges, including federal, state, and local
taxes; security and lodging fees; and booking or service fees from the hotel
and/or the web site.
-- Beware of potential bias. The screens on the leading independent travel web
sites are inundated with banners, pop-ups, pop-unders, and even rate listings
that are bought and paid for with hotel advertising and marketing dollars.
Make sure that you've examined all the choices before booking.
-- Never book a hotel room online until you've read and understood the
cancellation policy. Many independent travel web sites charge additional fees
for changes and cancellations, in addition to fees levied by the hotel.
-- If you know the specific hotel property you want to visit, conduct an
online search and find the branded web site for that hotel (which may be
maintained by either the chain or the property itself). The chances are good
that you may find a lower rate there. In fact, when Consumer WebWatch queried
rates at specific properties, lower rates were returned by the branded sites
in 1 out of 3 cases.
-- When shopping for hotel rates online, always ensure that you are extremely
accurate about the information you input. For example, many hotel chains
maintain properties with similar-sounding names (e.g., "Marriott
Downtown" vs. "Marriott Midtown" or "Holiday Inn
Airport" vs. "Holiday Inn Airport North"). If you're comparing
rates for a specific property, determine its full address and zip code before
comparison shopping on other sites.
-- Be very careful when comparison shopping from site to site. During the
course of this testing, Consumer WebWatch found numerous problems with the
default functions on some travel sites. Each site may not store and
"remember" the information you input as you shop, so the data you
entered may be lost and the search engine may revert to incorrect dates or
locations.
-- Use a credit card for online purchases. Credit cards generally provide the
most federal consumer protections in the United States. Under the Fair Credit
Billing Act, your liability for unauthorized charges is limited to $50 -- if
you report the billing error to the credit card company in writing within 60
days after the bill was mailed to you. Credit card companies and e-merchants
may cover this fee in certain situations. Some credit card companies also will
let you use a temporary "throw-away" credit card number when making
purchases online, so that payments are credited to your actual credit card but
without your needing to share electronically your real account number or
password. Inquire with your credit card company about this option. You may
also want to consider setting aside a single credit card for online use. That
way, if a security breach occurs, you will still be able to use your other
credit cards.
e-Ratings of hotel-booking sites, based on the results of this report, will be
available to consumers later this year. For the near term, consumers can go to
www.consumerreports.org to access an article that summarizes the findings from
the research report. The full results from this study can be found at
www.consumerwebwatch.org.
Consumer WebWatch Also Takes A Closer Look at Search & Health
In addition to the hotel-booking study, Consumer WebWatch today unveiled
findings from four new research reports on search engines and health sites at
its first national summit on Web credibility, entitled "Building Trust on
the Web."
Consumer WebWatch commissioned Context-based Research Group, a Baltimore-based
anthropological firm, to conduct an ethnographic study that examined
consumers' attitudes toward the pay-for-placement practices employed by some
search engine Web sites. The study revealed that all 17 of its participants
were surprised to learn commonly used search engines are paid to list some
results and sites more prominently than others and changed their search
behavior as a result. Specifically, many respondents claimed that they were
less likely to trust the first result listed, or even the entire first page of
listings, upon learning about the pay-for-placement practice.
While some said they had no real aversion to the practice, they did stress
that paid links and ads should be more clearly marked to distinguish them from
"pure" search listings. These findings among others prompted some
study participants to speculate that the practice would become less tolerable
as consumer understanding of pay-for-placement marketing increases. The
ethnographic approach enabled Context researchers to spend a significant
period of time with each participant in their natural setting, observing what
they actually do versus relying on what they say they do.
In January of 2003, the Health Improvement Institute (HII) and Consumer
WebWatch initiated a research project to examine the credibility of health Web
sites by first looking at guidelines available from various entities. The
study found that there are no criteria readily available to consumers or to
professionals that allow them to assess the credibility and reliability of
health Web sites. In the next phase of the project, the Institute intends to
develop, test, and apply such a tool that will produce independent ratings of
health Web sites. The tool will allow a user to judge a site's ease of use as
well as its purpose, sponsors, currency and sources.
The Consumer WebWatch mission is to investigate; inform; and improve the
credibility of information on the Web. ConsumerWebWatch.org is home to
research and analysis on issues of credibility, usability and content, along
with news of use to consumers navigating the Web.
Consumer WebWatch is a project of Consumers Union, the non-profit publisher of
Consumer Reports magazine and ConsumerReports.org. The project is supported by
The Pew Charitable Trusts, which invests in ideas that fuel timely action and
results; the John S. and James L. Knight Foundation, which promotes excellence
in journalism worldwide and invests in the vitality of 26 U.S. communities;
and the Open Society Institute, which encourages debate in areas in which one
view of an issue dominates all others.
The material above is intended for use by legitimate news entities only; it
may not be used for commercial or promotional purposes. Consumer Reports(R) is
published by Consumers Union, an independent, nonprofit testing and
information-gathering organization, serving only the consumer. We are a
comprehensive source of unbiased advice about products and services, personal
finance, health, nutrition, and other consumer concerns. Since 1936, our
mission has been to test products, inform the public, and protect consumers.
IT&CMA
2003 Gets Strong Support From ICCA
The
International Congress and Conventions Association (ICCA) will be holding the
7th ICCA Congress & Exhibition in the city of Busan, Korea on 26 – 29
October 2003. As one of IT&CMA’s Endorsing Association, ICCA has
declared its strong support for IT&CMA 2003 by ensuring that the dates of
ICCA Congress does not clash with those of IT&CMA 2003. Delegates of the
Congress will hence be able to attend IT&CMA 2003 the following week, 4
– 6 November 2003 in Bangkok, Thailand.
The
prestigious ICCA Congress & Exhibition only takes place in Asia
Pacific every three or four years, and is a great opportunity for Asian MICE
specialists to learn more about international meetings, as well as to network
with senior directors and specialist managers from the world's leading meeting
venues and specialised service providers.
"We
strongly believe that Asian meetings professionals can benefit enormously from
attending both the ICCA Congress and the IT&CMA Show, and we hope that
many delegates take up both opportunities. Both events offer critical yet
complementary business opportunities for our members, and in this year of
business and economic uncertainty it is vital that no such opportunities are
missed,” said Martin Sirk, ICCA's Chief Executive Officer.
This year
there is a distinctive Asian flavour to ICCA's educational programme, which
will be showcasing "Asian Expertise" for CEO's and other senior
delegates, and "Critical Skills" for senior and middle managers.
Case studies, client panels and interactive sessions will all be featured.
ICCA's
Congress also offers unique business opportunities, with a
business-to-business exhibition, Business Leads Exchanges, Data Workshops for
research specialists, and specialist sessions run within ICCA's
sector-specific Category structure.
To find out more about
ICCA and its Congress, go to www.iccaworld.com/7congress
.
Travel
trade launches ‘We love HK’ campaign to boost spending
TravelWeeklyEast.com - Cathay
Pacific Airways, Dragonair, and five other carriers are participating in a
“We love HK” campaign to encourage consumer spending at home, and
instilling confidence in the community.
The campaign, to be launched on May 1, has also generated interest from all
sectors of the travel trade and the community at large, including Ocean Park,
Star Cruises, hotels, restaurants, and taxi drivers, as no registration is
required for participation. Anyone can join, anytime.
The idea, championed by Cathay Pacific Airways, is simple. Consumers who
spend HK$1,000 for a local tour organised by the Travel Industry Council
(TIC); book a local hotel package through a registered TIC member; and/or
spend money at a restaurant or shopping centre are eligible to redeem air
tickets; discounts on flights to regional and long-haul destinations or other
deals.
The only restriction is a maximum of HK$300 can be spent at a retail
outlet. Redemptions for air travel must be made through travel agents, who
will charge an HK$100 processing fee.
Cathay is initially offering 2,000 tickets to Tokyo, Osaka, Bali and Seoul
for HK$1,000 until June 30, but will consider extending this date, should the
campaign progress well.
Dane Cheng, general manager, sales for Hong Kong and China says, “This is
an important self-help initiative for the industry. The idea is to get the
people of Hong Kong to go out and spend some money. It’s also a great way to
get people to know more about their own city and back on airplanes.”
Dragonair is kicking off the campaign by offering $1,000 airfares to Phuket,
and says it will not rule out the possibility of offering a second destination
if the campaign moves forward smoothly. Titus Diu, deputy general manager,
Hong Kong for the airline says the carrier will go a step further and extend
the date of travel to the end of July.
Five other carriers: Northwest, Air Canada, Qantas, Finnair and Virgin
Atlantic have already pledged support, while United Airlines and Air France
say they are exploring ways for getting involved.
Gilbert Chow, vice chairman of the Board of Airline Representatives and
general manager, Hong Kong for Northwest says, “We believe it is very
important that we go back to our normal lives. There is a danger that we will
defeat ourselves before SARS destroys us.”
Chow says Northwest is working out ways to participate and will likely
offer air tickets and hotel packages to Japan. “For instance, there are now
air + hotel packages for 3 nights/4days at $3,000 dollars, so we might offer
it at $1,000. We haven’t decided, but should know within the next two or
three days,” he said.
Finnair’s country sales manager, Hong Kong and Taiwan, Jere Tala says his
carrier will offer tickets to Bangkok for HK$900 until end June, and will
continue to assess the situation on offers for longhaul destinations. “We
will at least offer Bangkok, Ithis is going to be successful, then we will
consider to extend to European destinations. We hope that this will wake up
the public's appetite for travelling again.”
Forrester:
Don't Ignore The Small Business Traveller
Opportunity
knocks in the small business travel sector but many of the larger travel
companies aren't listening
Micro Enterprise Journal -
On the whole, much of the travel industry ignores what it considers
"small" accounts — companies that spend less than $1 million
annually on business travel. Forrester Research, in a recently published brief
entitled Exploiting Small Firms' Focused Travel Tech Needs, concludes
that this is a market that deserves more attention.
While they are smaller businesses than the huge corporate
accounts, these businesses are big enough to have designated travel managers
and fairly beefy travel budgets. When Forrester conducted a survey of 380 of
these travel managers, they discovered that these "small" accounts
spend an average of more than $725,000 a year on airline tickets, Amtrak,
accommodations and auto rentals.
Meanwhile, these companies may or may not use travel
management companies (TMCs) like American Express, WorldTravel BTI or
Rosenbluth International, but Forrester found that neither TMCs nor booking
engines meet both the needs and the budgets of these smaller firms.
Generally speaking, booking engines (software applications
used by travel managers to manage the company's travel requirements) are
optimized for larger accounts. For a TMC to meet their travel needs, they
would have to provide the small business travel manager with good advice to
help them with some key tasks: saving money on travel management fees, finding
technological solutions to improve productivity of traveling personnel, and
evaluating new travel technologies.
Without that kind of customer service, and without the will
to make themselves more attractive to the small account customer than the big
three of Expedia, Orbitz and Travelocity, Forrester envisions that most TMCs
will abandon any attempt to shave off a cut of this market.
Another trend that may be worthy of note is that, while these
customers are not likely to be spending a lot of their budgets on fancy
travel-related software applications, they will be spending on communications
technologies. For microbusinesses serving this market, real opportunities
exist in mobile and wireless communications, mostly in the form of service
packages, and in videoconferencing.
With the travel industry in general, and the airlines in
particular, taking a beating as one thing after another takes a bite out of
industry stability, microbusiness travel agents may be doing themselves a
favor to target the smaller of these "small account" businesses. It
may be worthwhile, for example, to use a bit of ingenuity and savvy to put
together a package of services for these customers. In such an ailing
industry, taking advantage of market opportunities like this are just the kind
of thing that help microbusinesses to ride out the storm.
Le
Méridien’s Madrid Ritz sold to Orient-Express JV
e-tid.com
-
Orient-Express Hotels and Spanish investment group Omega Capital have
agreed a €125m (£86.5m) deal to purchase the Hotel Ritz in Madrid from Le Méridien.
The 167-room hotel will be operated by Orient-Express under a long-term
management contract.
Commenting on the acquisition Simon Sherwood, president of Orient-Express
Hotels, said: ‘We are proud to have been able to acquire this world-famous
landmark property together with Omega and to manage it within Orient-Express
Hotels.
‘We have agreed with Omega on a €25m improvement plan that will include a
conservatory type dining terrace, additional and better conference, spa and
banqueting facilities, upgrade of technical aspects and enhancements of the
garden.’
The
Madrid Ritz takes Orient-Express’ hotel portfolio to 42 in 17 countries
worldwide. It is the company’s second property in Spain after La
Residencia in Majorca, acquired from Sir Richard Branson’s Virgin
Hotels in February 2002. Orient-Express also operates tourist trains,
restaurants and a river cruiser.
|