Newsletter - March 22, 2002
UP
TO 27% REVPAR UPLIFT WHEN HOTEL OWNERS
PARTNER GLOBAL AND NATIONAL BRANDS
But hotel owners say ‘brands good, but not that good’
- Brand operators have to work harder to close gap in
perception over value of their brands
A new European
report by KPMG, the professional services firm, has revealed a substantial
gap in perception between owners and operators over how much RevPar uplift
(revenue per available room) can be achieved when brand operators manage
hotels, compared to the RevPar achieved by independent hotels.
Hotel owners believe that global brand operators achieve, on
average, a RevPar uplift of 16%. But
brand operators said this uplift was 25% – a discrepancy of nearly 10%.
The difference is even greater when looking at national
brands. Owners believed
national brand operators uplift RevPar by 11%, compared to operators who
said this figure was 27%.
Hotel operators are having to work harder at their
partnerships with owners, in order to convince owners of the benefits of
working with global and national brands
Both owners and operators need to work together to create a
successful and profitable alliance, which will maximise the return on
investment that can be generated from rooms.
They need to make the most of the brand value of hotel operators,
and target customers effectively through their distribution systems and
brand loyalty schemes.
With competition getting fiercer, operators are under
pressure to offer attractive deals to hotel owners. At present, approximately 25% of European hotel stock is
branded, compared to 70% in the US, so hotel operators are looking to
Europe to grow their market share and boost revenues.
Nick Pattie, Director of Hospitality at KPMG, speaking at the
Hotel Investment Forum in Berlin, said:
“Hotel owners are much more knowledgeable about hotel operations
and are becoming increasingly sophisticated when selecting brand
operators. Owners are looking
for greater flexibility and transparency from operators, and performance
guarantees are becoming essential for contracts.
Greater emphasis is being placed on profitability as a key
performance indicator, and the ability to control costs, such as capital
expenditure. In the long
term, operators will probably have to be more flexible on lengths of
contracts if they want to partner hotel owners.”
Owners and operators have identified a number of areas they
need to address:
Effective brand management: Both
owners and operators need to exploit management and distribution systems
to generate the maximum return on investment.
The backing of strong brands can also help owners secure funds from
investors. Operators want to
ensure that brands have consistent standards across all hotels.
More flexibility in working
relationships: Owners would
like shorter contracts to protect them from the risks associated with
hotel brands changing hands, and different market conditions. Operators, on the other hand, would like longer contracts to
maintain and protect brand presence.
Owners would also like to see more agility and creativity in the
design and refurbishment of hotels to reflect changing market demands.
Improved financial control and
reporting methods: Owners are
keen to encourage shared decision-making over finances, have more
influence over budgets, and a clearer understanding of the accountability
of the general manager and his team.
Greater transparency:
Many hidden costs are perceived as being passed on to owners.
Owners would like to have more influence and understanding of how
costs are allocated and charged back.
Sharing of Risk:
Owners, particularly of smaller hotels or those operating in
volatile markets, would like operators to take an equity stake in hotels.
They believe this would encourage operators to focus on profit
maximisation.
·
KPMG carried out the research for their hotel performance
survey between December 2001 & February 2002. Novotel Hotels, and
Radisson Edwardian
·
Interviews were held within the top end of the hotel market
across six of the leading European markets: UK, Germany, France,
Netherlands, Spain and Greece.
Participants included: Hilton
International, Hospitality Europe, Meridien Hotels Ltd,
KPMG’s Travel
Leisure and Tourism team is active throughout Europe and comprises a team
of professionals who specialise in providing advisory services to large
and mid-market clients in the Travel, Leisure and Tourism marketplace. These services include financial management, IT, profit
improvement, and strategic planning.
KPMG
is the global professional services firm whose aim is to turn
understanding of information, industries, and business trends into value.
With more than 100,000 people worldwide, KPMG provides assurance,
tax and legal, financial advisory and consultancy services for more than
760 cities in 155 countries.
HOTEL
CHAIN CONTINUES MOVE INTO NEW YORK CITY
Three
months after opening its first hotel in New York City, Hampton Inns, a
mid-price subsidiary of the Hilton Hotels Corporation, is adding four
properties in the city, three in Manhattan and one in Queens. Like the
earlier Hampton, all four hotels are to be built from the ground up,
rather than converted from other hotel brands or other buildings.
Although
Hampton has 1,180 hotels in 49 states (all except Hawaii) and in a
sprinkling of foreign countries, it currently has none in Manhattan.
Like
about 95 percent of all the hotels that bear the Hampton name, the hotels
in New York City will be franchises. While the company would not disclose
the cost of the individual projects, it said the five New York City
hotels, including the Hampton that opened in Queens near Kennedy
International Airport at the beginning of the year, had a total cost of
about $130 million.
The
first Hampton hotel in Manhattan is scheduled to be a 144-room property in
Chelsea at 108 West 24th Street, between Avenue of the Americas and
Seventh Avenue, which has a prospective opening date in October. A 65-room
property at 320 Pearl Street, near the South Street Seaport, is expected
to open in December. A 136-room hotel at 116 West 31st Street, near Herald
Square, is to open in May 2003. The Chelsea and Herald Square buildings
will be 19 stories. The 220-room hotel scheduled for Queens, which was
designed by the architectural firm of Cherniahivsky & Associates of
Philadelphia, is expected to open in 2004, at 102-10 East Ditmars
Boulevard, across from La Guardia Airport. Its franchise owner, Field
Hotel Associates of King of Prussia, Pa., also owns the 216-room Hampton
Inn-Kennedy Airport.
All
three Hamptons scheduled for Manhattan, designed by Gene Kaufman
Architect, are being built by
the Hersha Group, a family business in New Cumberland, Pa. Hersha owns and
operates 27 hotels, including a 79-room Holiday Inn Express in Long Island
City and a 120-room Doubletree Club at Kennedy Airport.
Rooms at
Hamptons typically cost $66 to $99 a night nationwide, depending on
location, according to Phil Cordell, senior vice president of
Memphis-based Hampton. But rates at Hampton's properties in Manhattan are
likely to be at least double that. Room prices at the Hampton hotels in
Chelsea, Herald Square and on Pearl Street are projected to range from
$160 to $225.
There are no
projections yet for the hotel near La Guardia, but rates at the Hampton
Inn at Kennedy Airport are about $129 on Monday through Thursday, $109 on
Sunday and $114 on Friday or Saturday.
The reasons
for the higher room rates in New York are familiar: the high cost of land
and construction, as well as the many regulatory hurdles. "Compared
to suburban locations, the same size hotel built in New York is at least
three times more," said Neil H. Shah, Hersha's director of
development.
Nevertheless,
Mr. Shah was quick to add, "Once you're up and running in New York,
you're in the best hotel market in the world."
That market
has been struggling in recent months. In its latest survey of trends in
the hotel industry, PKF Consulting found that occupancy in New York City
fell 5.5 percent this January, to 62.5 percent, compared with a year
earlier, and the average daily room price dropped 12.1 percent, to
$181.50. Those figures are a far cry from 2000, when the city's occupancy
rate was 84.6 percent and the average price was $237.
Nevertheless,
with the economy beginning to inch upward, executives of Hampton, the
Hersha Group and Field Hotel Associates express confidence that the
cyclical hotel market will turn around before long.
"As an
industry, we've gone through peaks and valleys," said Mr. Cordell of
Hampton, "and I'm absolutely confident this cycle will head back
up."
Mr. Shah
sounds equally optimistic partly because of the economy; because of New
York's many strengths; and because "it's not like bringing just any
new hotel into town — Hampton's a `killer brand.' " In each of the
last three years the chain has won the J. D. Power & Associates award
for "highest guest satisfaction among midprice hotel chains with
limited food service."
Hampton, which
was founded in 1982, was acquired by Hilton in 1999 when it took over the
Promus Corporation. This put the chain within Hilton's centralized
reservations system and meant that a person seeking lodging at another
Hilton property might be referred to Hampton if the first choice is sold
out. Hampton participated in Hilton's HHonors Program, which awards
airline miles and hotel points, redeemable for airline tickets, cruises,
entertainment and merchandise.
"Hampton
has always had a loyal group of customers," said Gary Isenberg,
Field's executive vice president for hotel operations. "But being
under the Hilton umbrella has made Hampton even stronger."
DESIGN HOTELS REDEFINE ‘LUXURY’
Sandra
Hoffmann in Hamburg reports on the boom in hotels for the rich and hip.
Many hotels' concepts
of luxury used to be flock wallpaper, heavy velvet drapes and chandeliers.
But now hotel owners are discovering that travelers are prepared to pay
for top-class design and more individual character.
The latest example of
a design hotel is the Hotel Side in Hamburg, Germany, that opened in
April.
The 178 rooms and
suites grouped round a large glass atrium 24 metres high were designed by
star architect Matteo Thun from Milan.
He describes his
minimalist room as "classic-modern". White furniture and pale
fabrics made of high-quality natural materials contrast with dark wooden
floors to deliver an understated and functional effect.
But in the spa in the
lower part of the five-star hotel, Thun has splashed out with some colour.
The basement is decorated with sunny yellow, orange and green walls and
sea-coloured glass mosaics.
"I wanted people
to forget they were underground," said Thun.
US artist Robert
Wilson devised the lighting concept for the atrium.
"A room is
nothing without light," he said.
The computer-
controlled lighting system aims to reflect the changes of mood throughout
the day, depending on the weather and the time of year.
Claus Sendlinger, one
of the founders of the Design Hotels Marketing Cooperative, set up in
1993, said he now receives one enquiry a week from people wanting to build
a design hotel.
"But only those
that really have something to offer will survive," he said.
Nearly 170 hotels in
32 countries are now members of the organisation, which has its German
headquarters in Augsburg, Bavaria.
This means more than
just hanging up a few modern paintings and placing some bright modern
sofas in the reception lounge, he said.
"It is about
creating a diversion from normal daily life in a hotel, giving it a
special character with unexpected things," said Sendlinger.
A design hotel is not
a fashionable hotel, it must have a holistic concept, he said.
"Then it will be
able to survive over decades, because good architecture remains super for
many years."
Nevertheless they will
occasionally need a freshen up, like the Radisson SAS Royal Hotel in
Copenhagen, which claims to be the first design hotel.
It has just spent 8.7
million US dollars refurbishing the luxury 22-storey building that was
originally designed in 1960 by Danish architect Arne Jacobsen (1902-1971).
Windows throughout the
rooms give guests the sensation of floating over the city. Lime green
furniture fabrics, maple wood panelling and lights in turquoise and blue
tones convey a sense of brightness.
Yet despite the
complete renovation, they have remained true to Jacobsen's original
design. All the rooms still contain the designer's famous swan easy
chairs, Series 7 chairs, and the original lamps.
In homage to the
original design, Room 606 has been maintained in its original form. The
lobby has also remained largely unchanged.
Alongside the original
Swan chairs from the 60s, are Jacobsen's somewhat larger Egg chairs that
were specially designed to "wrap up" prominent guests to hide
them from prying eyes.
Thirty years after
Jacobsen's masterpiece, many more hotels in New York, London and Paris are
now turning to top designers to lend them a special character.
Ian Schrager, the
former nightclub owner from New York, has opened a number of design
hotels. The first was Morgans in New York, followed by others in Los
Angeles and Miami. Schrager has worked mostly with star French designer
Philippe Starck.
They also developed
Schrager's first hotel in Europe together, the St. Martin's Lane Hotel in
London.
Also in London is the
One Aldwych that opened in Summer 1998, defined by its owners as a new
type of luxury hotel.
"Luxury hotels
still have a rather classic-traditional concept of luxury. Particularly in
London, this means chandeliers and heavy red velvet drapery," said
Dagmar Krausse, of the One Aldwych press office.
But the luxury in One
Aldwych is under-stated, and it has an extensive art collection "that
the director bought personally", said Krausse.
Art, as well as decor,
also takes centre stage in the two art'otels in Berlin and Dresden.
They are very
individually designed, each dedicated to an important artist," said
David Selle of the art'otel in central Berlin. Dresden is dedicated to A.R.
Penck, Berlin to Georg Baselitz.
The concept works,
said Selle. "People are prepared to pay for individuality."
Next spring art'otel
will open a new hotel in Berlin dedicated to pop artist Andy Warhol.
HOSPITALITY LEADER’S SUMMIT HIGHLIGHTS
EUROPE’S HUGE GROWTH POTENTIAL
Although 2002 will be
a challenging year for the tourism and hospitality industry, the outlook
for growth in Europe - in terms of demand, job creation and subsequent
investment in the industry - is extremely positive in the medium to longer
term. This good news for the travel and tourism industry, investors and
national economies, was the main message to emerge from the hospitality
Leaders' Summit convened in Berlin today.
The Summit brought together more than 40 CEOs of the major lodging groups,
between them representing over three million hotel rooms. This unique
event was convened by the International Hotel & Restaurant Association
(IH&RA), the World Travel & Tourism Council (WTTC) and the
International Hospitality Investment Forum (IHIF). Discussions and
debates, chaired by Sir Ian Prosser, Chairman of both Six Continents and
WTTC, centred on the current and future prospects of the industry,
security measures being taken post-11 September, and the need for
recognition of tourism as a driver of economic growth in Europe.
It is clear from our discussions today that, despite the events of the
last few months, the industry's outlook for the future is extremely
positive, said Sir Ian.
According to Jean-Claude Baumgarten, president of WTTC, the terrorist
attacks of 11 September and underlying recession will result in a decline
of 7.4 per cent in total travel and tourism demand in 2001-02, and will
cost the industry over 10 million jobs worldwide. But WTTC forecasts are
bullish for the longer term.
In 2003 travel and tourism demand is projected to rebound sharply, with
the result that, by first quarter 2004, the industry should have fully
recovered from the impact of 11 September, growing by 6.5 per cent.
Looking further ahead, travel and tourism demand is expected to grow by an
average of 4.5 per cent a year between 2002 and 2012.
Paul Slattery, Director Dresdner Kleinwort Wasserstein, shared this
optimism. He set the scene with forecasts showing that in Europe, even
with a modest 1 per cent compound annual growth rate, almost half a
million new hotel rooms would be needed to satisfy consumer demand over
the next ten years. On these assumptions additional capital investment of
some ¤4 billion would be required. However, this could only be achieved
if the structure of the European hotel industry and access to capital were
radically overhauled.
At the same time it is important not to forget the hard-learnt lessons of
11 September. According to Eric Pfeffer, President of IH&RA, safety
and security had already been identified as one of the major forces
driving change in the hospitality industry. The tragic events of 11
September dramatically heightened awareness of this key issue.
Participants acknowledged that security measures were vital and that hotel
companies had to remain vigilant and attentive in the current environment.
At the same time, governments who systematically tend to underestimate the
role of travel and tourism, had been made dramatically aware of the
industry's importance through the losses incurred over the past six
months.
The time is now ripe for the industry as a whole to raise its profile both
at the European and international level, said Pfeffer, highlighting the
role of the IH&RA in ensuring this representation.
While it is difficult for a horizontal industry such as travel and tourism
to speak with one voice, James Provan, Vice President of the European
Parliament, said it was essential for all industry partners to pull
together to achieve this objective.
For many participants it came as some surprise to learn that an industry
accounting for 20 million jobs and 12 per cent of European Union GDP not
only lacks representation commensurate with its economic importance, but
also the means to influence industry-relevant policy matters.
Organisers of the Leaders' Summit look forward to continuing this type of
dialogue - initiated by IH&RA in London in November 2000 - as one of
the many ways of raising the industry's profile.
CUBAN
HOTELS INDUSTRY THRIVING WITH FOREIGN PARTNERS
The world is
surfing Havana's tourist boom, as Bernd Kubisch reports from Havana.
Following the boom in
Cuba's tourism industry in recent years, there is now a strong upswing
underway with joint venture projects.
From now on, all new
projects for large-sized hotels of the four- and five-star category for
the socialist country's state-owned hotel chain will be realised only via
capital investment and management agreements with foreign partners.
This has been
confirmed by Emilio Falcon, president of the Cuba's hotel federation, who
inists: "Every deal we make is a good one."
The fact that foreign
involvement as a rule may not exceed 50 percent is no hindrance, Falcon
says. He regrets the fact that so far German involvement in Cuba has been
restricted to the management of vacation hotels.
According to the
Tourism Ministry, at the start of 2001 there were 27 hotel companies
involving foreign partners, combining for a commitment to build 15,600
rooms. So far, 3,700 rooms have been completed.
At the same time, 50
out of the 227 hotels meant for foreign visitors to Cuba are under foreign
management, with this trend strongly on the rise. At the end of 2000,
there were 36,000 hotel rooms in Cuba, while by the end of this year the
figures is to reach 40,000 rooms.
Many foreign hotel
partners are manager and shareholder at the same time, in some cases the
stakes being just 20 or 30 percent.
"We have capital
shares in some of our hotels," notes Carlos Villota, general manager
of the Melia Cohiba Hotel in Havana. The Sol Melia company was the first
foreign partner for Cuba, and in the meantime the Spanish group will soon
be managing 23 hotels, three of which are under construction.
Villota said that the
Melia Cohiba hotel is booked to 76 percent capacity, at a room price of
USD 215.
A number of hotels
have more than two partners. For example, the Cuban and Dutch flags fly
atop the Golden Tulip Parque Central in downtown Havana.
The state hotel chain
Cubanacan is a 50 percent owner, while the Dutch manage the hotel and
investors from four countries, including Britain and Italy, hold the
remaining stake.
"This is working
excellently," said Falcon, who is resident manager of the hotel.
Other foreign hotel
management groups who are satisfied with the situation include Super
Clubs, LTI and Oeger. They have set up offices and are aggressively
advertising their products.
By contrast, foreign
capital partners, for example from Canada or Sweden, are less hungry for
publicity.
Oeger Tour has shelved
earlier plans to participate financially in a 1,000-bed complex on Cayo
Coco.
"We are going to
operate and manage the facility because that is cheaper," said
company spokesman Ingo Thiel, while saying in this way Oeger's standards
can be guaranteed.
LTI marketing chief,
Monika Singer, says that her company is "very satisfied with the
cooperation" with the Cubans.
Soon the LTI Varadero
Beach Resort with 400 rooms is to be opened, followed next winter with the
317-room LTI Panorama Havana. This will bring to five the number of hotels
under the group's management.
Meanwhile Jag Mehta, a
consultant to Super Clubs, reports that "we are making good
profits".
Last February, the
all-inclusive hotel management company from Jamaica opened the Breezes
Costa Verde hotel, with 480 rooms, in Holguin. Owners are Cubanacan and an
Italian group.
"The interest of
foreign partners has grown strongly," said Mario Sori, vice president
of Cubanacan. "We would be very pleased about a joint venture with
Germany."
Manuel Estefania, vice
president of the Gran Caribe company, notes that "the Germans bring
us the most tourists, but are still reserved about investing".
At the end of 2000,
Gran Caribe had 41 hotels with 10,300 rooms, and the chain now has lined
up four capital partners - two from Canada and one each from Italy and
Sweden - for major new projects.
Meanwhile classic
hotels like the Inglaterra and Plaza in Havana have been modernised and
are being operated by Gran Caribe itself.
The ongoing boom in
vacationers is expected to add further momentum to joint ventures.
The number of visitors
from around the world rose from 1.603 million in 1999 to 1.774 million
last year.
Of that, Germans
accounted for 182,159 and 203,403, respectively. Cuba's tourism income is
now running at about two billion dollars a year.
HOTEL VALUES FALL
IN 2001
The value of hotel
properties fell by an average 2.6% across Europe in 2001, compared with an
increase of 7.8% in 2000, says consultancy HVS International.
Its European Hotel
Valuation Index shows the largest gains in value were enjoyed by hotels in
Moscow (16.9%), Milan (6.6%), Frankfurt (6.4%), Munich (5.1%) and Berlin
(3.8%).
The largest falls in
value were experienced by hotels in Istanbul (14.2%), London (13.3%) and
Hamburg (9.1%).
For 2002, HVS
International expects hotel values across Europe to see moderate growth of
only 1.3%, with only five markets seeing values decline, mainly as a
result of increased supply through new hotels being built. These markets
are Barcelona, Copenhagen, Dublin, Madrid and Warsaw.
For 2003, HVS expects
values to rise by 3.9%. The European Hotel Valuation Index 2002 was
launched at the International Hotel Investment Conference being held this
week in Berlin, Germany.
Source: Caterer &
Hotelkeeper
‘ULTIMATE
SERVICE AWARD’ WINNERS ANNOUNCED
The winners of the CNN
and American Express-promoted Ultimate Service Awards have been announced
at the International Hotel Investment Forum in Berlin, Germany.
Hotels receiving the
awards were as follows:
Africa:
Sheraton, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia
Asia: Ritz Carlton, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
Australia/New
Zealand/Pacific Isles:
Four Points by Sheraton, Sydney, Australia
Caribbean/Central
America (tied vote):
Hotel Cariblue, Puerto Viejo, Costa Rica, and JW Marriott, Mexico City
Europe: Courtyard by Marriott, Kassel, Germany
Indian
Sub-Continent/Indian Ocean:
Kandalama Hotel, Dambulla, Sri Lanka
Middle
East: Ritz Carlton, Sharm El Sheikh, Egypt
North
America: Doubletree Park Place, Minneapolis, USA
South
America: Hotel Sofitel, Bogota, Columbia
Votes were called for
via a 30-second commercial on CNN, banner advertisements on CNN.com and
through American Express, which targeted frequent hotel stayers via direct
mail. More than 3,000 votes were cast for hotels that business and leisure
travellers thought offered exceptional levels of service.
The awards were also
supported by Taylor Nelson Sofres, which ran the online voting system, and
Villery & Boch, which designed the crystal awards.;
Source: Caterer
& Hotelkeeper
HOTEL
MAN GETS WTTC ADVISOR ROLE
The World Travel &
Tourism Council (WTTC) has appointed Insignia Hotels’ Jonathan Worsley
as an advisor.
Worsley has held a key role helping US real estate giant Insignia
establish a European presence. He confounded and organises the annual
International Hotel Investment Forum, held in Berlin.
WTTC president Jean-Claude Baumgarten said: "Jonathan will be a great
ambassador for the WTTC in helping to link the hotel sector with the
travel and tourism related industries including airlines, travel agents,
tour operators, manufacturers, financial services and rental car
companies".
According to Worsley: "With the difficulties of 2001, it has become
even more important to have an open dialogue with governments to ensure
that the industry is represented at the highest levels".
CHINA'S
JIN JIANG INTN'L MANAGEMENT CORP SIGNS JV DEAL WITH ACCOR
Asia Pulse...
China's Jin Jiang
International Management Corporation and Europe's Accor hotels have signed
a joint venture agreement in preparation for an April launch of its new
domestic sales and distribution network targeting the China market.
Accor Jin
Jiang Hotel Distribution Co Ltd, which remains subject to final government
approval, will commence with the opening of a Shanghai head office before
the end of April.
It will represent three, four and five-star hotels
managed by both groups and staff recruitment has begun with the number
expected to reach 20 as demand increases.
Additional
offices will be opened in Beijing and Guangzhou in the coming months
covering the greater metropolitan area of all three major commercial
centres, in addition to Xian, Chengdu and Xiamen.
Accor
vice president of sales and marketing Rob Hornman said in a statement that
the joint venture would utilise Accor's key account management system to
identify accounts on behalf of the combined hotel network.
|